When a Prospect Says “Too Expensive,” Do Not Reach for the Discount

By Mike Bruce, Brand Consultant and Founder, Mike Bruce Design
Professional seated at a conference table in a modern office speaking toward a camera during a business meeting or interview

A prospect says the price is more than expected. The rep hears a verdict on the number and, within a day, a discount is on its way. The deal closes and the team tells itself the price was the problem.

Usually it was not. “Too expensive” is a comparison, and nobody makes it in a vacuum. The buyer is holding your price against something: a rival’s quote, last year’s spend, a cheaper supplier, or doing nothing. The sales leader’s job is to find out which – before anyone touches the number.

Three Objections Hide in One Sentence

Coach your team to sort every price objection into one of three types:

  1. “We cannot afford this.” The budget is genuinely not there. This is the rarest type, and it’s the only one a discount can fix. It usually means the wrong buyer is in the pipeline – and that’s a qualification problem, not a pricing one.
  2. “We cannot see the difference.” The money exists but the buyer cannot tell why this offer costs more than the alternative. This is the most common type. A discount makes it worse, because it confirms the suspicion that the two offers were the same thing at different prices.
  3. “We cannot see the cost of waiting.” The buyer understands the difference but feels no urgency. The problem being solved feels like next quarter’s problem.

A quick test separates them. Ask: “If our price matched the other option, would you choose us?” A fast yes points to type three: urgency. A hesitation points to type two, difference. A flat “we just do not have it” points to type one, and the right move is to thank the buyer and move on.

Why the Discount Costs More Than It Feels Like

A discount feels small, but price is the strongest profit lever a company has. In a widely cited analysis, Michael Marn and Robert Rosiello (Harvard Business Review, September to October 1992) found that, for a company with average economics, a 1% improvement in price – with volume held constant – raised operating profit by 11.1%. A 1% increase in volume raised it by 3.3%.

Read that backwards. On the same simple arithmetic, a 5% discount that brings no extra volume would remove more than half of the operating profit of that average company. It is a rough calculation, and every business has its own numbers, but the direction is clear: Discounts need a plan, not a reflex.

There is a second cost that never appears in the accounts: A discount teaches the market that the price is negotiable. Every buyer who hears about it starts the next conversation lower.

A 10-Minute Test for the Sales Leader

Before changing any price, find out what your buyers are comparing you with. Pick three prospects who said no (or went quiet) after seeing a quote. Ask each one a single question: “When you looked at our proposal, what did you put it next to?”

Write the answers down word for word. Two patterns tend to appear. If all three name the same rival, then that rival is your real competitor, and your team should prepare a direct answer to it. If the answers differ widely, or the prospect struggles to say, then the buyer could not tell what makes you different, and no discount will repair that.

Three Checks for Your Sales Material

  • The substitution test. Take your last proposal and remove the name and logo. Put it beside a rival’s proposal with theirs removed. Could a buyer tell which one is yours? If not, price is the only visible difference.
  • The sentence test. Ask three team members, separately, to finish this sentence: “We cost more than the alternative because…” If you receive three different answers, or the answers are all “quality,” “service” and “experience,” then buyers are receiving the same fog. Those words are claimed by every company in every category.
  • The evidence test. For each claim in your material, find one proof point that could replace it. “We deliver results” is a claim. A named customer, a measured outcome, and a timeframe are evidence.

How to Coach Reps Not to Open with a Discount

  1. Slow the first reaction. Train reps to answer a price objection with a question, not an offer. “Compared with what?” costs nothing and reveals which of the three types is in play.
  2. Give reps a one-sentence answer to “Why does this cost more?” that they can say without notes. If the team cannot agree on the sentence, then fix that before the next round of calls.
  3. Set a discount rule. Decide in advance what may be traded and what must be given in return, such as a longer term, an earlier start, or a reference. Never discount for free.
  4. Log every objection. For the next 10 price objections, record the buyer’s exact words and tag each one as type one, two, or three. After 10, the pattern usually points to a single fix.
  5. Review lost deals by objection type, not by price paid. A pipeline full of type-two objections is a message problem, which belongs to the whole company, not only to the sales team.

What to Do This Week

Ask three lost prospects what they compared you with. Run the substitution test on your last three proposals. Then hold one meeting with your team to agree the one-sentence answer to “Why does this cost more?” Only after that should anyone discuss the discount.

When the buyer can see the difference, price stops being the whole conversation – and the discount stops being the first move.

Mike Bruce is a brand consultant and founder of Mike Bruce Design in Abuja, Nigeria. Mike Bruce works with companies across Nigeria, the UK, and the U.S. on positioning and pricing.